Introduction and Objectives
The aim of this paper is to explore questions
of consciousness and the varying philosophies of relationships of a self to a
body, analyzing the way this self/body interacts with its external environment,
and with other self/bodies. This being thoroughly examined, we are able to
understand how the science of existence supports the philosophies of
existentialism and logotherapy, and how we can create our own meaning and value
through art, creativity, and deliberate choices of consciousness.
Consciousness: Mysticism and Neuroscience
“I not only have a body, I am
a body.”
“I do not have a soul. I am a soul. I have a body.”
What does it mean to “be”? There is a struggle
within humans, a struggle between the romantic world of metaphysics and the
hard, logical world of neuroscience. We struggle to understand just who or what
“we” are– a body, or a brain, or a spirit. There is a certain fetishism toward
the idea of the unconscious; there is a mystique, a way of separating this
unconscious “self” from the fleshy spatio-temporal body that physically
interacts with the outside world. I recently attended a lecture by Doctor Sant
Dharamananda, who holds a doctorate in Eastern Philosophy, in which he
described humanity as “spiritual beings trying to have a human experience”.
This view implies a separation of the mind and the body, and it implies that my
brain doesn’t need “me”. It implies that I own
this body and I own this brain, but
am not limited to these entities. It also assumes that something beyond my
flesh experiences my life, and this body is simply a mediation between “me” and
the outside world.
In an attempt to connect metaphysics with
science, these ideas (or ideals)
relate to René Descartes’ Cartesian
Dualism, the theory that the mind and the brain consist of two different
substances. The mind is non-physical, takes up no space and has no position.
The body, brain, and physical world, on the other hand, are made of something
solid, something that can be measured and described. Descartes argues that the
two interact only through the pineal gland, the part of the brain that produces
serotonin and affects our wake/sleep cycles, though he provides no explanation
as to why this is the only physical part of the body that is able to
communicate with the spiritual or mental realm.
 |
| Salvador Dalî, Sleep, 1937. Surrealism is an arts movement known for separating the subconscious mind from the logical, physical world. |
|
Neuroscience, on the other hand, has shed
itself of any romanticism. The majority of neuroscientific research and writing
will agree that we are nothing more than our bodies– in some cases,
consciousness is regarded as simply a pleasant side-effect to existence.
There is a repeated question throughout both
philosophy and neuroscience: how do I know where I begin and end? Where does my
physical self end and an environment begin? How do I know this hand is mine? In
order to be self-conscious, we must be able to identify this boundary– or at
least be aware of any abstraction of it. One simple way to approach the
question of self-identification is to turn again to science; take, for example,
a skin transplant. Should you need to replace lost skin from a wound on your
forehead, you may “borrow” and transplant skin from any other part of your
body– your thigh, your stomach, anywhere. The only skin that works is yours, or in some cases, the skin of an
identical twin, regardless of what part of the body it comes from. While it may
be conceptually heavy to consider the borderline between self and non-self,
your body knows the answer already. Your DNA and natural chemicals are able to
recognize what comes from “you” and what does not.
Our relationships to our bodies are complicated
and open to a number of different interpretations and therefore, different
approaches. In Freud’s analysis of the psychological self, we are comprised of
three different inner “selves”; the id, the ego, and the superego. The id is
the unorganized and uncontrollable subconscious, acting according to the
pleasure principle and seeking primarily to avoid any pain or displeasure. This
relates most closely, perhaps, to the mind that is considered to be separate
from our physical forms– the part we can’t quite find or control. The ego, on
the other hand, is our conscious perception of our selves. Lastly is the
super-ego, or the ego ideal. It is our potentiality, our projected selves, and
the consciously or unconsciously desired state of being each individual longs
for privately. The ego attempts to mediate between this desired image and the
hidden desires of the id.
With this basic groundwork laid out, we can
begin to explore the relationship of a person to his or her self. Consider the human as a machine, a
faceless skeleton with a set chemical and organic structures. What makes each
individual different? There are physical differences that allow us to
distinguish our relatives from strangers, as well as differences within
individual personalities. Humans naturally strive to be distinguishable as an
individual as well as part of a cultural or social group. This is where the
social body becomes part of the conversation between the ego and the super ego.
It is almost impossible to escape the social
and cultural associations of the body; to analyze the body without looking
through a lens of social idealism. Therefore, the body itself becomes damaged
by ideological comparative analyses. Through our experiences, we create an individual
ideal– sometimes different but inseparable from the pre-established mass or
social principles. This is the birth of the super-ego, the “could-be” or
potentiality of a being. Especially in contemporary western and internet
culture, sub-cultural ideals are apparent. They are defined and strived for by
the individual, who wishes to be perceived in a certain way. Therefore, the ego
strives to be the super-ego but is unable to escape the id.
It is
important to note that it is impossible to lump the psyches of the entirety of
the human species into psychological sub-categories. It simply cannot be proven
that every individual lives between his id-ego-super-ego, just as it cannot be
proven that there is or is not a separation of the mind and the body. Language,
labels, and equations are entirely inadequate for describing the way each
individual develops a personality and a sense of self. Mind versus body, self
versus non-self, and self versus desired self are each important dualities to
consider in moving forward and thinking about ways of existence.
The Self in Space, The Body in Space
The sense of one’s own body in space is called proprioception. The dictionary
definition of proprioception reads, “the perception of movement
and spatial orientation
arising from stimuli
within the body
itself”. This is often considered the “sixth sense”. At times,
our proprioception is conscious; we
are aware of our body and our surrounding space. Oftentimes, we’re not aware of
this unless something is obstructing our usual flow-of-motion, or if we’re
particularly focused on our position– such as in a dance. More often than not,
however, our sense of proprioception is unconscious,
and our relationship to space is passive.
We label our spaces in our lives based on their
assigned functionality. “Bedroom”, “marketplace”, “kitchen”, “park”– all of
these words carry a connotation and association with them. When we occupy one
of these spaces, our brains call back on stored memories, and we know what to
do with it based on our knowledge of that space’s pre-determined function and
our past experiences in similar spaces. We see a chair and we know we should
sit on it– there is no active interaction with/awareness of the object that is
the chair itself.
Space is only perceived by a body. We
previously discussed the possible role of the fleshy body as a mediator between
the “self” and the tangible world. The being becomes oriented in time and space,
and codes the actions of that space by choosing how to interact with it. The
body in space has a potentiality for play, violence, passivity, and so on.
The body in space also becomes mentally
integrated into that space. A room, as well as the objects in it, become a part
of our brain’s body maps, which is our brain’s awareness of each individual
nerve in our body. Through interacting with a space and with objects, we are
relatively extending our bodies.
 |
| Rebecca Horn, Finger Gloves, 1972 |
There is a Marxian question accompanying the
science of proprioception. Marx wondered whether a spider, when building its
own web, is obeying blind instinct or has (or is) an intelligence. It produces the web from its own bodily
secretions to accommodate its own survival needs. Should we consider this an
abstract space that is separate from the spider and his or her body, or is it
more true to say the spider builds its web as an extension of its body? That
being considered, are human spaces so abstract and separate from ourselves, or
are they, too, extensions of “us”?
Rebecca Horn is a prime example of an artist
working with these ideas. Her early work is performative, utilizing sculptures
that attach to the body to create extensions of the physical being into space.
She is interested in the balance between the figure and objects, between flesh
and other substances.
In one of her earlier pieces, Finger Gloves, Horn created finger
extensions using cloth and balsa wood. “An instrument to extend the manual sensibility…
I can feel, grasp, touch anything with them, but keep a certain distance from
the objects… I feel me touching, I see me grasping, I control the distance
between me and the objects” (12). This follows the neuroscientific theory that
when we wear a tall hat or use a tool such as tongs, our brain’s map of our
body extends to include that object. Horn’s work functions almost directly as
proof of this phenomenon.
In her other pieces, Horn extends other parts
of the body through a variety of tactics. She creates sculptural extensions of
arms, legs, the head, and so on. In some experiments, she utilizes feathers as
an alternate to human flesh. She describes the sensation of wearing feathered
finger extensions; “I touch my bare left hand with my feather-dressed right
hand, start to touch it and stroke and carefully examine this new experience.
It is as if one hand had suddenly become disconnected from the other, like two
utterly unrelated beings. My sense of touch becomes so disrupted that the
different behavior of each hand triggers contradictory sensations” (Haenlein
66). Her sculptural/performative works allow the wearer to re-identify their
bodies, to find extended forms of self-perception.
Existing, Existence, Existentialism
“We always find something, don’t we, to give us the impression we
exist?”
-Samuel
Becket, Waiting for Godot
We’ve examined the human relationship of a self
to a body and a body to its space and time. We’ve examined neuroscientific
evidence of a direct, inseparable mind-body relationship, and from here on we
will consider existence through this lens; that we are, in entirety, a single
bodily object.
This is a difficult perspective for many to
accept. As Rita Carter puts it in her book, Mapping
the Mind, “Human beings are natural born soul makers, adept at extracting
unobservable minds from the behavior of observable bodies” (Carter 17). It is
difficult to settle with the idea that your legacy dies with you, and that
friends and loved one’s will also come to an end. It is difficult not to search
for a higher meaning, an excuse for consciousness, a metaphysical reason for
the beautiful chaos that is the very existence of a life.
Many (if not, most) religions deal with a
higher power that bestows a meaning or fate upon each individual or larger
group, with the promise that a soul will be rewarded to live on beyond the body.
Buddhism is the only religious system to reject the idea of a persisting inner
self or a soul– that is, a separate mind and body. If we can step away from the
religious and move toward the philosophical, however, we find a place where the
facts of neuroscience, semiotics, and ethics meet; existentialism.
The most basic explanation of existentialism is
that it is a philosophy that rejects the idea of a religious or metaphysical
higher calling. Instead, there is no assigned meaning to life. Although this
particular theory of existence is at first off-putting and often connoted as a
negative philosophical system, many people understand existentialism as a
philosophical source of human empowerment. With no prescriptions or written (“biblical”)
manual on how to live, each and every individual is able to select his or her own
path and, therefore, create his or her own value and meaning. A lazy person may
find this intimidating, while others will find it empowering.
One of the most important existential
philosophers, Sartre, famously stated that “existence precedes essence”; that
is, the fact that we exist is the basis for how we choose to interact with the
world. Sartre is also noted for stating that “we are given choices– within the
limits of our given world”. The ability to choose our own path and create our
own essence is fully within our power– there is no metaphysical force driving
us, and we cannot escape the hard facts of reality. The physical world is very
much so the “real” world.
Many artists have worked with or written about
different theories of existence. Joseph Kosuth is notable among these artists.
Part of the Art and Language group of
the minimalist and conceptual 1960's, Kosuth made work dealing with semiotics,
post-structuralist ideas, and ecological relationships between humans, art,
culture, time, and environments. His work often directly utilizes definitions
as a way to critique the systems of language. In one piece, he printed and
framed the meaning of the word “meaning”. The self-reflexivity of art, culture,
and meaning unto themselves is a primary concern of Kosuth’s.
In another piece– perhaps his most famous-
titled One and Three Chairs, Kosuth
juxtaposed an actual chair, an image of a chair, and the definition of the word
“chair”. In these works, the viewer is made to consider how we understand an
object; whether that be through its physical properties, our past experiences
with similar objects, or through our linguistic signifers of the object. In the
end, we usually understand how to interact with an object that is a “chair”
before we think any more about it. However, according to Kosuth, in an arts
context, the object always “stands for” an artist’s ideas, rather than actually
acting as an object, because the meaning bestowed on it rests outside of its
normal functionality or thingness.
In his writing, Joseph Kosuth consistently
makes a point of noting that art is beautiful in its uselessness. Art exists
for its own sake, much like the existentialist idea of conscious beings
creating their own meaning and existing only within themselves. Kosuth rejects
mystical or transcendental art, noting that art can never be truly experienced outside
of the concreteness of the world and the viewer’s sensory perception.
 |
Joseph Kosuth, One and Three Chairs, 1965. Joseph
Kosuth’s work explores semiotic interpretations of
language, space, meaning, and objects. |
In
opposition to existentialism is experientialism; the belief that the world and
definitions do not exist, but only the experiencer exists. The conscious being
is defined as being “constantly enlarged by [his] own experiences” (Bronowski
18).
Another
opposing force is modal realism– which declares that “possible” worlds (or
“imaginary” worlds) are as real as the actual world. This theory goes
hand-in-hand or is a sub-part of the quantum theory, which was inadvertently
developed by Einstein, in spite of the fact that the truth of this theory would
completely negate his own rules of existence developed in the theory of
relativity. In this case, things
are only “real” because they are perceived by a being to be there. “Does the
moon only exist when you look at it?”, Einstein once asked his colleague, the
biographer Abraham Pais. These systems also reference Platonic realism, and
other popular theories.
While
these claims oppose existentialism and the solidness of existing in a physical,
actual world, the theories have a common string; individuals are left to define
their own meaning within their own time and space.
Art and Value: Art
Outside of Arts Practice
There is
a difference between American Existentialism and European Existentialism; in
the American notion, individuals are concerned with “discovering” the self. This
approach assumes that there is a small kernel of the authentic self buried deep
down within your consciousness that is incredibly difficult to attain. This can
only be discovered by shedding the meaningless clutter to try to find that tiny
piece of authenticity within yourself.
The
American perspective borders on the metaphysical; it suggests that there is a
prescribed mission to be accomplished. In the European version, however, there
is a focus on the self-making of the
self. In both versions of existentialism, we exist only in our actions.
Choices
must be made; will your actions be of value, or not? What is the definition of
value for you, personally? Every being is
something, would like to be something,
and has the potential to be anything
else. A person and his or her consciousness is comprised of the relationship of
his or her actuality and potentiality, much like Freud’s id, ego, and
super-ego.
The
responsibility of creating meaning falls onto each individual.
I sense a
pull within humanity to be both recognized as individuals who can be
distinguished from other individuals, and yet still feel a sense of belonging
to a group. There is a search for meaning in every person, and each person finds
it somewhere differently. Some people subscribe to religions or social groups
or subcultures, others may shut themselves out and become introspective
academics. Others yet may seem to waste their time on meaningless whims. In all
cases, it is possible that the individual may never even realize that he or she
is searching for meaning.
This
corresponds with Viktor Frankl’s logotherapy, a psychological system that
focuses on man’s search for meaning, rather than the Freudian search for
pleasure. Frankl points out that psychotherapy is focused on introspection,
whereas in logotherapy the patient looks to the future. “The patient is
actually confronted with and reoriented toward the meaning of his life” (Frankl
153). Meaning is not something that emerges from existence, but something that
confronts or responds to the state of existence. A conscious being is given a
choice to find his or her meaning in a lifetime– and even simply in single
moments.
The
greatest enemies of meaning are boredom and/or too deep a search for pleasure.
Frankl often urges patients to view their life from their deathbeds. Was life a
waste of time? Did you spend your time attending parties and having good
nights, but end your time alone and sad, with nothing of value to hold on to?
Or, do you find yourself on your deathbed reflecting on a valuable life, a life
that achieved something meaningful and worthwhile to you? No one can tell you how to create this meaning, you must both
define and validate it for yourself.
Being creative
and, as a result, productive, for many people, can generate both pleasure and
meaning. This is part of why alternative therapies (such as art, movement, or
wilderness therapies) can be effective substitutes for psychotherapy. Rather
than sitting on a couch and talking, the patient is actively doing something that makes their time
feel worthwhile. Hobbies such as the ones employed in active therapies help to
develop a sense of value, esteem, ownership, and mental flexibility by
activating new parts of the brain. They can also assist as calming or
expressive activities. In the Freudian school, therapeutic activities such as
painting are considered to be a way of giving external life to inner worlds,
bringing unconscious or repressed instincts to the surface. In other words, the
art happens “in between” the inner and outer worlds.
Art and
creativity can also be used within communities both inside and outside of a
therapy context. It’s said that, at it’s best, a community not only coexists
together, but creates together. A
creative community works together to solve personal and interpersonal problems.
In a group therapy situation,
working in a collaborative group can act as a microcosm for social
reality, in which group members learn their role and are able to understand
their own contributions as a single part to a whole.
In
organizations such as Minneapolis’s Kulture Klub Collaborative, which works
with teens who are experiencing homelessness, art is used in a similar way- as
a tool for developing ownership, esteem, and even skills that make participants
more competitive for careers. The organization perpetuates creative thinking
and instills a sense of meaning, value, and collaboration within two
marginalized groups– both homeless teens and the artists working with them. In
this sense, art-making and creating are largely about empowerment.
Fine art–
outside of the world of therapy or professional non-profits- also has a
practice within perpetuating meaning. Previously, we read about Joseph Kosuth’s
praise of art’s uselessness as its source of beauty. Does “use” translate into
“meaning”? How can art create a valuable experience, rather than an object with
monetary value? This is especially relevant to ephemeral works of art, such as
site-specific installations or performance pieces, such as the “Art as Life”
pieces and writings by Allan Kaprow or the realistic yet absurd performances by
Fluxus artists. There is not a price to be put on these works, only an
authentic value that comes from the experience itself.
Conclusion
Our
brains are wired to our sense of selves > Our sense of ourselves comes from
our perception of the outside world > Our perception of the outside world is
our consciousness > Our consciousness is our existence > Our existence is
our meaning > Our meaning is self-created. By borrowing from the
philosophies of existentialism and logotherapy, we can be empowered to create
meaning for ourselves through art. Art can function as a tool to create
personal meaning or relay personal ideologies, a tool to create value within
communities, or a tool for healing.
Bibliography
Adamson, Edward. Art as Healing. London: Coventure, LTD,
1984. Print.
Blackmore, Susan. Consciousness: A Very Short Introduction.
New York City: Oxford University Press,
2005. Print.
Bronowski, J. The Identity of Man. Revised ed. Garden
City: The American Museum of Natural
History, 1966. Print.
Carter, Rita. Mapping the Mind. Revised ed. Los
Angeles: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 2010. Print.
Case, Caroline, and Tessa Dalley.
The Handbook of Art Therapy. London:
Routledge, 1992. Print.
Dharamananda, Sant. "The 5
Senses and The 7 Chakras." Minneapolis College of Art and Design. Minneapolis. 10 Oct. 2011. Lecture.
Frankl, Viktor E. Man's Search For Meaning. Revised ed.
New York City: Beacon Press, 1963. Print.
Freud, Sigmund. The Ego and The Id. Standard ed. New
York City: W.W. Norton and Company, 1960.
Print.
Haenlein, Carl, ed. Rebecca Horn: THe Glance of Infinity.
New York City: Scalo Verlag, 1997. Print.
Holl, Steven. Parallax. New York City: Princeton
Architectural Press, 2000. Print.
La Lune Rebelle. Stuttgart: Dr. Cantz'she Druckerei, 1993. Print.
LeDoux, Joseph. Synaptic Self. London: Penguin Books,
2002. Print.
Lefebvre, Henri. The
Production of Space. Malden: Blackwell Publishers, 1974. Print.
May, Rollo, ed. Existential Psychology. Second ed. New
York City: Random House, 1969. Print.
"Rebecca Horn." The Centre for Contemporary Art. N.p.,
26 Oct. 1999. Web. 30 Oct. 2011.
<http://csw.art.pl/new/99/rebecca_e.html>.
Rebecca Horn. New York City: The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation,
1995. Print.
Rebecca Horn - Official Website. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 Oct. 2011.
<http://www.rebecca- horn.de/pages/biography.html>.
Rebecca Horn. Zürich: Kunsthaus Zürich, 1983. Print.
Wooley, Benjamin. Virtual Worlds. Cambridge: Blackwell
Publishers, 1992. Print.
Zinker, Joseph. Creative
Process in Gestalt Therapy. First Vintage ed. New York City: Random
House, 1977. Print.